Wang and Zhou promote the five algebraically independent matter invariants of three-flavour oscillations to exact first integrals of the matter RGEs, using $S_3$ covariance under mass-eigenstate relabelling and pole-cancellation of the $1/\widetilde\Delta_{ij}$ terms. Only two independent monomial invariants survive, reproducing Naumov and Toshev. The four-flavour extension gives eleven invariants and shows the electron-sterile spurion obstructs any monomial invariant — a sharp structural criterion for sterile searches.
hep-phAbstract
We utilize renormalization group equations (RGEs) for neutrino oscillations in matter to decipher the structure of exact matter invariants. By combining the RGEs with the $S^{}_3$ permutation covariance under relabeling of the neutrino mass eigenstates, we recast all five algebraically independent matter invariants in the three-flavor framework as exact first integrals. Treating the matter potential as a matter spurion and imposing the cancellation conditions for the $1/\widetildeΔ_{ij}^{}$ poles in the RGEs, we further prove that the three-flavor framework contains only two independent monomial invariants, which can be related to the Naumov and Toshev relations. We then extend the analysis to the four-flavor framework, where we uncover a complete set of eleven algebraically independent matter invariants and prove that the rank-two electron--sterile spurion obstructs the common pole cancellation required for any nontrivial multiplicative monomial invariant.